Journal Info

Baseball

What an earned run average does not measure

An earned run average credits a pitcher for outcomes his fielders and his home park helped produce. Here is the arithmetic, the definition of an earned run, and a worked example showing how a park shifts a pitcher's raw number.

By Journal Info Editorial Team · Published 2026-11-17

The MLB glossary calls earned run average the most commonly accepted statistical tool for evaluating pitchers (MLB Glossary — Earned Run Average). It looks like a simple rate — runs allowed per nine innings — but every clause in that description does work, and one of them, “earned,” carries a judgement about what the pitcher is responsible for that the box score cannot settle.

This article takes the formula apart, defines the earned run by contrast with the unearned one, and works through the two distortions that matter most when comparing pitchers.

The formula

Earned run average is 9 × earned runs ÷ innings pitched (MLB Glossary — Earned Run Average). The nine scales the rate to a nine-inning game, so the number reads as earned runs per nine innings.

The odd component is the innings figure. An inning has three outs, so every out a pitcher records is worth one-third of an inning pitched (MLB Glossary — Innings Pitched). Check how your source writes partial innings: many lines write a third as .1 and two-thirds as .2, which are not decimals. Adding such figures as ordinary decimals goes wrong. Convert to outs first, add the outs, then convert back. For example, 180.2 innings is 180 × 3 + 2 = 542 outs and 6.1 innings is 6 × 3 + 1 = 19 outs. Together they make 561 outs, which is 187.0 innings; adding the notation as decimals gives 186.3, which would be read as 186 and one-third, a whole two-thirds of an inning short.

Earned versus unearned

An earned run is a run charged to a pitcher that scored without help from an error or a passed ball; an unearned run did score with that help, and it is excluded from ERA (MLB Glossary — Earned Run). If no errors or passed balls occur in an inning or a game, every run in it is earned. If a pitcher leaves with runners on base, earned runs scored by those runners count against him.

The glossary notes that it is often the official scorer’s judgment whether a specific run would have scored without the defensive mishap. For the reader, the practical consequence is that earned run average depends in part on a scorer’s decision, not only on events on the field.

A worked example

Consider a hypothetical pitcher with a clean season line:

  • Innings pitched: 180 (recorded as 180.0)
  • Earned runs: 62
  • Unearned runs: 8
  • Total runs: 70

Earned run average is 62 × 9 ÷ 180 = 3.10. If the unearned runs were counted too, the figure would be 70 × 9 ÷ 180 = 3.50. The 0.40 gap is the difference between counting earned runs only and counting all runs, here the 8 unearned runs spread over 180 innings (8 × 9 ÷ 180).

The glossary also warns that the ballpark can affect ERA, because some stadiums are more conducive to run scoring. A 3.10 posted in a park that suppresses scoring is not directly comparable to a 3.10 posted in a park that inflates it, because the run environment behind each figure differs.

The two distortions that matter

Defence behind the pitcher. The glossary’s own description of the flaw is that fielding errors are held against run prevention while outstanding defensive plays earn no credit, so a pitcher backed by an average defence is at a disadvantage to one backed by a great defence. Fielding percentage, which is putouts plus assists divided by chances (putouts, assists and errors) (MLB Glossary — Fielding Percentage), does not fill the gap: by that formula a ball a fielder could not reach is never a chance, so range does not appear in it.

Park and league. Some stadiums are more conducive to run scoring, and the glossary adds that, with no designated hitter in the National League, pitchers there tended to post lower ERAs, which makes comparison across the two leagues hard. That entry describes the older rule: the glossary’s designated-hitter entry says the National League adopted the DH as part of the 2022-26 collective bargaining agreement, so the point matters mainly when comparing seasons before and after the change (MLB Glossary — Designated Hitter Rule). A comparison across parks, leagues or eras should state the raw environment or use a figure adjusted for it.

What ERA is still good for

None of this makes earned run average useless. It is a direct, published, widely available record of runs allowed per nine innings, and it answers a real question: how many runs did this pitcher’s innings cost his team. That is the number that goes into the standings.

What it does not do is isolate the pitcher’s own contribution. Wins above replacement is an alternative that estimates how many more wins a player is worth than a replacement-level player; for pitchers, versions use either runs allowed per nine innings or fielding-independent pitching, adjusted for league and ballpark (MLB Glossary — Wins Above Replacement). Different versions differ, so read which one you are looking at. Neither measure is the truth; they answer different questions.

Rechecking an ERA yourself

The steps are short:

  1. Convert innings to outs: multiply the whole innings by three and add the thirds (180.2 innings is 542 outs).
  2. Confirm the earned-run figure with the scorer’s record, not with total runs.
  3. Compute earned runs × 9 ÷ innings.
  4. If you are comparing two pitchers in different parks, look for a park-adjusted figure before drawing a conclusion.

The most common reader error is using total runs instead of earned runs, which silently folds every error in the season into the pitcher’s rate.

Method

The pitcher is invented. ERA, the earned-versus-total comparison and the innings-to-outs arithmetic were computed by script. The glossary entries behind this note were opened on 2026-10-31.

Sources

AI assistance recorded as: AI draft, not edited

Back to the notebook